The largest US
drug-store chain by sales, Walgreen Co., is seeking an emergency injunction to stop the
city from banning the sale of cigarettes and other tobacco products at
pharmacies. A hearing on Walgreen’s motion will be held September 30. The ban
is expected to take effect October 1 if Walgreen’s motion won’t be successful
and would affect 52 Walgreen pharmacies in San Francisco.
The measure was approved in July by the San Francisco Board
of Supervisors and signed by Mayor Gavin Newsom last month, making the city the
first in the nation to ban tobacco sales in pharmacies. The ban was modeled on
similar bans in eight Canadian provinces and was supported by the California
Medical Association and the American Cancer Society. At the time, San Francisco
Supervisors claimed that sick people shouldn’t be faced with cancer-causing
products while getting their prescriptions filled. Today the organization is
scheduled to vote on another piece of anti-smoking legislation that would
restrict smoking in a wide array of public places.
According to the San
Francisco’s law, prohibits "any retail
establishment in which the profession of pharmacy is practiced” is forbidden to
sell tobacco products, “unless the retail establishment is a general grocery
store or a big-box store.”
This specific detail bothered Walgreens’ officials. Representative
Tiffani Bruce wanted to explain the chain’s position: “Our position is based
solely on being fair across different types of retailers. Our pharmacists are
trained to counsel smokers on smoking cessation products and how to go about
kicking their habit. This ordinance will discourage smokers from coming to a
place where they can have this type of access,” he said as quoted by the San
Francisco Chronicle.
Moreover, Walgreens’ attorneys called the ordinance “anti-competitive”
and “unconstitutional” because it “prohibits tobacco products sales at some
pharmacies, but not others, favoring some retail establishments that have
pharmacies but not others.”
The ban is just one of the measures taken by authorities
across the US against smoking,
but, although the number of those who smoke seems to lower, smoking is still
the biggest cause of preventable deaths in the US, killing more than 400,000
people each year.
Smoking causes nine out of 10 cases of lung cancer, the
leading cause of cancer death in men worldwide and the second-leading cause of
cancer death among women. Of course, there are also other conditions favored by
smoking such as heart disease, asthma and child birth defects in case of women
who smoke during pregnancy.
Also, secondhand smoking seems to be higher than previously
believed, killing almost 40,000 people annually because of cancers, respiratory
infections and asthma, conditions also diagnosed in the case of smokers.
At a global level, the World Health Organization estimates
that every year more than 1.4 million people die from lung cancer, which is the
leading cause of cancer death.