Over 45 million Americans – including over 8 million
children - lack health insurance, while some of the people having insurance struggle
to cope with soaring medical coasts. This is the picture of the US before the
presidential election in November. Given the circumstances, presidential
candidates Barack Obama and John McCain are playing their last card, namely
health care, hoping their plans would bring them people’s support and win the
election.
Until now, the balance appears to favor Obama’s plan that
wants to create a government-operated insurance program, which would require
larger employers to provide coverage for their workers in an attempt to reduce
the number of people without health insurance. In addition to this, people
won’t lose their insurance coverage when they switch jobs because their
insurance would be portable.
On the other hand, McCain’s health care plan would put an end to tax breaks
for health insurances provided by employers and come up with a refundable tax
credit of $2,500/person or $5,000/family. Referring to this particular matter,
Obama said a $5,000 tax credit sounds pretty good. “What McCain doesn’t tell
you is, the average cost of a family health care plan these days is more than
twice that much: $12,680. So where would that leave you? Broke,” he said during
a speech last Saturday while campaigning in the battleground state of Virginia.
McCain also wants to let people shop across state lines when buying
insurance; that would bypass states where insurance is more expensive and
comprehensive.
Obama’s plan would cover 34 million of the nation’s
projected 67 million uninsured people in 10 years, compared with just 2 million
covered under Republican John McCain’s Plan, according to a report released at
the end of September by the Commonwealth Fund.
Obama also plans to modernize the current system of
employer- and government-provided health care and to make some investments that
will lead to a more efficient medical system. He plans to invest more in preventive services,
like regular screenings and healthy lifestyle information.
Those who
are uninsured tend to believe Obama’s plan would be more likely to provide them
with coverage. In fact, according to a survey conducted September 17-21, 2001,
by telephone among a national cross section of 935 registered voters in the United States
found that more voters (33 percent) think Senator Barack Obama’s plan would be
better for them than Senator John McCain’s plan (27 percent).
Insurance for kids is also another point in Obama’s plan
that might bring him Americans’ votes, as it would mandate insurance for kids,
while McCain’s would not.
When it comes to costs, McCain’s plan was projected to coast
more than $2 trillion from 2010 through 2019, while Obama’s would cost $1.7
trillion, according to the analysis released this week. What is not known yet
is how the candidates would cover the total.
On the other hand, health economists are ideologically
divided over McCain’s plan. Supporters of the plan project it might provide
coverage to 25 million people, while critics predict that the number of newly
insured would peak at five million and then decline.