After multiple refusals from the creators of Scrabulous to
remove the application from Facebook, it appears that a lawsuit was the most
convincing method to force them make up their mind. Hasbro can now happily sit
and watch how North American users no longer have access to the online game.
While Hasbro, who owns the rights for Scrabble in North
America, has been trying for months to determine the Agarwalla brothers and
Facebook the shut down Scrabulous, users have also been fighting by all means
to get Scrabulous to stay.
When Hasbro filed a lawsuit this month for copyright
infringement, it seemed like there was no other choice for the Indian
developers of Scrabulous but to end their lucrative business on Facebook, which
earned them an estimated $25,000 a month.
But apparently, there was a way: a new Scrabble-like game, which
is not Scrabble… Sounds confusing? That’s because it is! Wordscraper resembles the
basic board of Scrabble, but it uses circles instead of square letters, has a
different pointing system, and has fewer chances to break copyrights,
specialists say.
Wordscraper did well this week for a “beginner,” attracting
thousands of players, probably ex-Scrabulous fans. However, there is still a
long way to go before it will be able to achieve the success of Scrabulous
(if it ever will).
While some players are grateful they haven’t lost their
favorite online application, others are very disappointed by Hasbro’s legal
move, claiming that the toy maker should be grateful to the Facebook app for
making players also go buy the actual game.
“Hasbro has an obligation to act appropriately against
infringement of our intellectual properties,” Hasbro said in a statement. “We
view the Scrabulous application as clear and blatant infringement of our
Scrabble intellectual property.”
Ever since appearing on Facebook, in May 2007, Scrabulous
has attracted millions of users, with 500,000 devoted users playing every day.
But what now, that Scrabulous is gone? Will Wordscraper take
its place? Or maybe the legal Scrabble online application from Hasbro and EA
will win the battle?
If we look at the users’ reaction, Scrabble for Facebook
brought by Hasbro/EA is far from being an accepted alternative. The best proof
for that was the attack that took the official game down, the same day
Scrabulous was taken off Facebook. Unbelievable coincidence or the work of some
angry Scrabulous fans, it’s hard to say.
So far, Facebook users seem pretty determined to prove
Hasbro that they made the wrong decision about Scrabulous. Some users promised
to never touch Scrabble by Hasbro/EA, while others promised they will boycott the
application.
Earlier this year, when Hasbro first made its claims against
Scrabulous public, thousands of fans created an online movement, “Save
Scrabulous,” meant to determine the toy maker drop its demands for the online
game to be pulled out.
However, Hasbro doesn’t seem to be willing to give up their
rights in North America over Srabble, and neither is Mattel, who owns the
intellectual rights in the rest of the world, including India, and is
apparently also suing the Indian developers.