A long-term study of more than 14,000 male
physicians concluded that taking daily supplements of vitamin E or vitamin C did
not prevent cardiovascular disease. A separate study involving 35,000 men found
that taking vitamin E and vitamin C supplements did not decrease prostate
cancer risk.
The National Cancer Institute decided to
suspend a study on the benefits of vitamin E and selenium supplements treatments
on prostate cancer prevention. The study, called SELECT (Selenium and Vitamin E
Cancer Prevention Trial), found a higher risk for aggressive prostate cancer in
participants taking only vitamin E and a small increased risk of developing
diabetes in subjects taking only selenium. The findings of the study were a
major disappointment to those that had hoped that these supplements might prove
to be some powerful anti-cancer agents.
“I am afraid it will be the end of the
story for large trials of vitamin E and selenium to prevent prostate cancer,”
said the study investigator Edward M. Messing, professor and chairman of
urology and deputy director of the Cancer
Center at the University of Rochester.
For the second study, scientists enrolled
14,641 male physicians, dividing them into four groups. The first group took 400
international units of vitamin E every other day and 500 milligrams of vitamin
C daily, the second group took vitamin E and a placebo vitamin C, participants
in the third group were given vitamin C and placebo vitamin E and the last took
only placebos.
After eight years, the rates of “major
cardiovascular events”, such as heart attack, stroke, congestive heart failure
or angina were similar among all four groups. Overall, there were 1,929 cases
of cancer, including 1,013 cases of prostate cancer. 490 men taking vitamin E
developed prostate cancer compared to 523 in the placebo group.
The results of the study, funded by the
National Institutes of Health and several vitamin makers, were reported Sunday at
an American Association for Cancer Research conference in Washington.
“After nearly 10 years of supplementation
with either vitamin E or vitamin C, we found no evidence supporting the use of
either supplement in the prevention of cancer,” Howard Sesso, an assistant
professor at Birmingham
and Women’s Hospital, says in a news release. “There are no compelling reasons
to take either vitamin E or C for cardiovascular disease prevention,” Sesso
said, adding that there was also no sign that either supplement was harmful. “We’re
still testing whether taking a standard multivitamin has an effect.”
There are some other steps you can take to
avoid heart disease: don’t smoke, get regular exercise and eat healthy foods. Studies
have shown a healthy diet, with lots of whole grains, fruits, vegetables and
nuts significantly reduces the risk of heart disease.
“The American Cancer Society recommends
getting these and other nutrients by eating a mostly plant-based diet with a
variety of vegetables, fruits and whole grains. A bonus is that this type of
diet helps to prevent obesity, which increases the risk of several cancers,” said
Marji McCullough, nutrition chief at the American Cancer Society.