A study publicized by U.S. researchers at an American Heart
Association meeting in New Orleans claims that the headphones of portable audio
players (iPods, other generic MP3 players) may interfere with the functionality
of cardiac equipment. The devices in question are pacemakers and implantable defibrillators,
which can malfunction if in close proximity to headphones.
Previously it had been thought that the players themselves
were the problem, but a study done earlier this year by the Food and Drug
Administration (FDA) showed conclusively that they posed no harm.
The headphones plugged into them, however, are another
story. The small speakers are based on equally small but powerful magnets. When
you place them within 1.2 inches of the cardiac equipment, a quarter of
patients will get interference, the study shows.
The team at the Medical Device Safety Institute at Beth
Israel Medical Center in Boston was lead by Dr. William Maisel, and tested
eight different models of headphones and ear buds, which were connected to
Apple iPods. The study was carried out on
60 patients; of those, fourteen patients experienced problems, and it was found
that defibrillators are twice as likely to be affected as pacemakers.
''For patients with pacemakers, exposure to the headphones can force the
device to deliver signals to the heart, causing it to beat without regard to
the patients' underlying heart rhythm,'' as Dr. Maisel has said in a press
statement. ''Exposure of a defibrillator to the headphones can
temporarily deactivate the defibrillator.''
The results come as no great surprise since users of this kind
of cardiac equipment are specifically prohibited from being in areas with
powerful magnetic fields, due to the devices’ sensitivity.
Maisel said that, while certain brands have been found to
have stronger magnetic fields than others, people should not focus on brands,
but rather keep their headphones at
least 1.2 inches (3 cm) away from the device. That means don’t keep the
headphones in your breast pocket or leave it dangling on your chest.
Otherwise, using MP3 players and headphones is perfectly
safe, according to Dr. Maisel: ''The main message here is: it's fine for
patients to use their headphones normally, meaning they can listen to music and
keep the headphones in their ears. But what they should not do is put the headphones
near their device.''
MP3 headphones are not the only devices to come under
scientific scrutiny for fear of them posing a danger to people with heart
problems. For instance, other studies that have been conducted by the American
Heart Foundation in regards to popular electronics have found no interference
to be caused by Bluetooth earpieces, the MP3 players themselves, electric
blankets, or metal detectors used at airports and hip-hop parties.