The giant New Zealand dairy co-operative Fonterra’s
criticizes the way Chinese authorities has handled the case of contaminated
baby milk formula that has made over 430 infants ill, its chief executive
Andrew Ferrier said on Monday.
He revealed that Fonterra, which owns 43 per cent of the
Chinese San Lu company that sold the baby food, urged its partner to withdraw
it all from sale at least a month before a full public recall was ordered.
But San Lu had no choice but to work within Chinese government guidelines,
Ferrier said in a video news conference from Singapore, on his way home to deal
with the crisis after cutting short a business trip.
Ferrier refused to speculate when asked whether the Chinese had wanted to cover
up the issue prior to the Beijing Olympics.
At least one baby is reported to have died after being given the formula which
was manufactured with milk contaminated by melamine, a toxin found in
fertilisers and cleaning products, and is blamed for causing kidney stones in
the sick infants.
Ferrier described it as "sabotage" but said it was not clear whether
the melamine had been added by farmers as a fake protein to bulk up their milk,
as has been reported from China, or if it was a deliberate attack on the San
Lu-Fonterra joint venture.
He said San Lu had withdrawn the contaminated formula from trade distribution
as soon as the board, which has three Fonterra representatives, was advised on
August 2, but a full public recall was not ordered until about a week ago,
following procedures laid down by the Chinese health ministry.
Calling it a "truly tragic occurrence," Ferrier said there was
"still an enormous amount of uncertainty about this" and the Chinese
authorities had now ordered a complete recall of all San Lu products.
He said that Fonterra would have preferred that the issue became public much
sooner than it did and was happy and relieved it was now in the public domain.
Ferrier said it was a "very serious issue" for Fonterra, which is the
world's biggest single exporter of dairy products, selling consumer goods and
food industry ingredients to 140 countries.
"We are doing all we can to assist the Chinese government and to put
systems in place so that it can never happen again," he said.
Earlier, Prime Minister Helen Clark said she had personally intervened after
learning of the problem and directed New Zealand's
ambassador to Beijing
to tell Chinese officials her government was extremely concerned that the
formula was still being sold.
Ferrier said the New Zealand
government's intervention had been very helpful.
Fonterra bought its stake in San Lu in 2005 as part of a strategy to get into
the fast-growing Chinese market and said the companies had a good relationship
but "everybody's going through a very tough time."
China's food industry has
been rocked by a number of scandals in recent years, undermining consumer trust
in Chinese food exports and increasing pressure from countries like the United States and Japan to improve food standards.
In 2007, toxic pet food and melamine-contaminated meat or wheat protein was
traced to Chinese producers, and a food scare in Japan
in early 2008 involved frozen dumplings imported from China.
© 2007 - 2009 - DPA/eFluxMedia