 |
|
|
Democrat Barack Obama’s plan would cover 34
million of the nation’s projected 67 million uninsured people in 10 years,
compared with just 2 million covered under Republican John McCain’s plan,
according to a report released by the Commonwealth Fund. A recent analysis
published in the journal Health Affairs suggests that the McCain’s plan will
lead employers to drop coverage for over 20 million Americans, while 21 million
people would gain coverage through the individual market.
McCain’s plan would eliminate tax breaks on
employer-sponsored health care benefits and instead give Americans tax credits
to seek their own plans in the private market. Individuals would get a $2,500
tax credit and families would get a $5,000 credit. The Arizona senator says his health care plan
would reduce the amount most Americans spend on health care by creating more
competition for insurance plans and better coverage options.
Obama, on the other hand, targets medium
and large companies where paying taxes is concerned, asking them to pour money
into a fund for the uninsured if they do not wish to provide their employees with
health-care coverage.
One of the problems that Obama has
identified in McCain’s plan is that he would offer tax credits to help families
pay for their insurance, but he would pay for these credits by taxing
employer-paid health care benefits. Earlier this week Obama launched an attack
on presidential rival John McCain’s health care proposal saying the plan would bring
higher taxes for working families.
“It’s a shell game. He gives you a tax
credit with one hand - but he raises your taxes with the other,” Obama said,
citing a survey by the Kaiser Family Foundation that showed the average cost of
a family health care plan is more than $12,000. Under McCain plan, tax credits
that will be given to Americans in order to help them pay for insurance will be
a $2,500 credit for individuals and a $5,000 credit for families.
Obama said that under McCain’s plan, younger,
healthier workers would buy cheaper insurance outside the workplace and many
employers will drop their health care plans altogether.
As for Obama’s plan, it is based on the
idea of expanding government health care. He plans to create a national
insurance program to support individuals who do not have employer-provided
health care and who don’t meet the criteria for the existing federal programs. He
would also modernize the current system of employer- and government-provided
health care. Critics say that his plan would give the government an unfair and
undesired advantage over private insurers.
Polls show voters favour Sen. Barack Obama in
the presidential contest, with health care as one of the most important issues
for voters. A survey carried out by the Harvard Public Opinion Research Program
at the Harvard School of Public Health and Harris Interactive found that 33%
favored Obama’s health care plan, while only 27% said John McCain’s plan was
better.
© 2007 - 2009 - eFluxMedia