Having prestigious Robert Redford as a director, lead actor and
producer, the movie “Lions for Lambs” treats the hot topic of America
politics about war inside and outside the country.
It’s a political drama about war as most critics say which opened in Germany on Thursday and the US on Friday.
Based on a screenplay written by Matthew Michael Carnahan who is
familiar with the topic of conventional terrorism from his previous script for
“The Kingdom”, the movie pictures Tom Cruise (Jasper Irving) as a slippery
Republican senator whose greatest desire is to become president; Robert Redford
as the idealistic college professor teaching political science and Meryl Streep
(Janine Roth), winner of two Oscars and six Golden Globes, as the world weary
journalist.
The action of the movie is divided into three plans of action all of
them happening at the same time in different locations.
First of them is located at an unnamed West Coast university where Redford’s character confronts an apathetic student Andrew
Garfield asking him why he has blown his class.
The second plan reveals Washington
D.C. and senator Cruise who
reveals a new war strategy to a TV journalist Streep, telling her: "You
sold the war. Now help me sell the solution.” Her response to the new strategy
is concluded in just one simple question: "What about looking at the
past?"
And finally the third plan of action is taking place in Afghanistan
where the new strategies arrive and where two soldiers Derek Luke and Michael
Pena fight for their lives.
The movie merges from one story to another revealing Redford’s personal
opinion about the American politics: media’s complicity in the current Middle East war, White House’s eagerness to win the war,
the apathy of young people and politicians who have never been implicated in a
war but are asking for supreme sacrifice from their military forces.
The consequences of the American politics of war in Afghanistan
play a secondary plan in this movie. There is no character from Afghanistan, just shadows in the snow planning
to kill the US
soldiers.
71-year-old Redford is not at his
first try to merge the politics with his work. He performed in “The Candidate”
in 1972, followed by “All The President’s Men” in 1976 with Dustin Hoffman, the
dramatic story of two Washington post
reporters who unveiled the Watergate scandal that ended President Richard Nixon
career at Washington.
"I'm always interested in the political scene. I have been since
1970, when I made ‘The Candidate,’ then ‘All the President's Men,’ then Quiz
Show,” he said on a short interview with dpa. But he wanted to add: “this one
is different, because this is about what is fundamentally unchanged. What are
the conditions that lead us into these situations that we find ourselves in
during McCarthy, during Watergate, during Iran-Contra, and here we are again.
What is underneath it that creates this?”
Speaking about his movie on the night of its gala on Tuesday, Cruise
wanted to clear the fact that politics is not one of his favorite subjects.
However, having the chance to play with Redford
and Streep was surely one of his greatest dreams. “I'm really proud to have
made the films I've made. I guess I've never taken for granted the
opportunities that I've had. This is a dream for me, truly it is," he said
according to the USA Today.
US critics had opposite reactions on Friday when “Lions for Lambs”
opened. Referring to its endless dialogues Variety magazine was not thrilled
about "star-heavy discourse that uses a lot of words to say nothing
new.”At the opposite side Hollywood Reporter praised Redford’s
intentions: "Politicians, the media, educators, military commanders and a
docile public all come under fire in a well-made movie that offers no answers
but raises many important questions."