J.K. Rowling Takes The Stand In Lexicon Case

By Chris Georg
22:44, April 14th 2008
59 votes
Vote this story
J.K. Rowling Takes The Stand In Lexicon Case

Testifying in court today in the ongoing the case of Warner Bros. and J.K. Rowling v. RDR Books, the British author nearly burst into tears as she defended her famed series "Harry Potter" from what she described as "wholesale theft".

"I really don't want to cry because I'm British," she said, looking just about to do that, "It means setting aside my children and everything."

The case, which Rowling stated is was not "about money," was started by the writer when RDR books attempted to publish a print version of a popular Harry Potter fan website, The Harry Potter Lexicon, created by Steven Vander Ark, who so accurately recounted the events in the books, that Rowling herself said she used the website to double check her facts while working on new material.

Rowling, who said she takes no pleasure in preventing the Lexicon's publication, adding that she feels "sad and disillusioned" the case ended up in court, claims in the lawsuit filed last year that there's too much of her own work in the Harry Potter Lexicon, including such things she invented for the Harry Potter series as spells, potions, magical creatures, Quidditch rules and wizarding history, and accused Ark of having "simply taken it and copied it."

"I think it's atrocious. I think it's sloppy. I think there's very little research It is sloppy, and it takes my work wholesale," she said in court today.

"What particularly galls is the lack of quotation marks. If Mr. Vander Ark had put quotation marks around everything he lifted, most of the Lexicon would be in quotation marks," she said.

"These characters meant so much to me - and continue to mean so much to me - over such a long period of time. It's very difficult for someone who is not a writer to understand. The closest I can come is to say to someone: 'How do you feel about your child?'," she tried to explain herself today.

"These books, they saved me - not just in a material way, though they did do that," she said. "I would have to say there were times when they saved my sanity."

However, RDR is not arguing against Rowling's copyright infringement claims, but rather insisting the book will serve a greater purpose, such as a scholarly pursuit.

On the other hand, Rowling also said not so long ago that she plans to write her own Harry Potter encyclopedia, which would include material that did not make it into the novels, but that she would donate the proceeds to charity.

Defending RDR, lawyer Anthony Falzone called the lexicon a reference guide, a legal effort "to organize and discuss the complicated and very elaborate world of Harry Potter," while also taking aim at Rowling's intentions of claiming "a monopoly on the right to publish literary reference guides, and other non-academic research, relating to her own fiction."

The fate of the book now lies in the hands of a New York judge who is set to decide whether the book, for which RDR said it would charge $24.95, will hit the stands in November as planned, or not, also taking into consideration Ark's own minor adjustments to the material. 



© 2007 - 2008 - eFluxMedia
dotclear

Other News in

Visiting Hawaii in Your Own Electric Car

Visiting Hawaii in Your Own Electric Car

Hawaii Gov. Linda Lingle announced Tuesday that the state wishes to link to the Better Place network of plug-in electric vehicles. Better Place, a venture-backed company designed to reduce demands on...

Relative Charged In Hudson Family Murders

Relative Charged In Hudson Family Murders

Tuesday, the Chicago police revealed that they had charged Jennifer Hudson’s brother-in-law William Balfour with the murders of the actress-singer’s mother, brother and nephew, adding the...

Experts Recommend More Sleep for Medical Residents

Experts Recommend More Sleep for Medical Residents

A panel of experts at the Institute of Medicine issued a recommendation to medical residents on Tuesday, which stated that medical and surgical residents in hospitals should work a maximum of...

Brad Pitt Builds 6 Homes for Hurricane-Struck Families, More to Follow

Brad Pitt Builds 6 Homes for Hurricane-Struck Families, More to Follow

Brad Pitt made several New Orleans families who lost their homes in the disaster caused by Hurricane Katrina happier. The well-known and wealthy actor built six houses in the Lower 9th Ward...

Elton John Is Elvis Costello’s First Guest on “Spectacle”

Elton John Is Elvis Costello’s First Guest on “Spectacle”

Some people know how to raise questions and others know (or at least should know) how to answer them. Elvis Costello has proved throughout time that he is the type of celebrity who is not afraid to...

dotclear
Latest videos in Specials
Heidi Calls 'Secret Show'...
Rice's royal recital
Japan noodles go American
Estranged Relative Arrested...
Cooking Bus to tackle obesity...

dotclear
Specials You are here: Specials
» Specials   
E-mail To A Friend Print RSS Text size: Decrease font size Increase font size
dotclear
dotclear
dotclear
Most Popular in Specials
Venus, Jupiter, The Moon: What A Trio In The SkyVenus, Jupiter, The Moon: What A Trio In The Sky

» read full story
dotclear

Interested In This Topic?

News Alert will keep you informed. Find out more.
dotclear
Photos Gallery
dotclear
Today's Latest News
Kristen Stewart to Play Rocker Joan Jett in BiopicKristen Stewart to Play Rocker Joan Jett in Biopic

» read full story
dotclear