New research on Medicare spending shows unexplained
variations in the amount, intensity and cost of care provided to Medicare
patients at the nation’s top academic medical centers in their last two years
of life.
The research follows rising in health care costs and a
report by Medicare’s trustees that the program’s hospital fund will go broke in
11 years.
Researchers at Darmouth
Medical School
used data on 192,242 Medicare patients treated at teaching hospitals who died
between 2001 and 2005, comparing the length of hospitalization, the number of
doctors treating them and the time they spent in intensive care units during
the last two years of their lives.
The researchers found huge differences in Medicare spending
among hospitals, raising the possibility that the government could save large
amounts of money. For example, total Medicare spending ranges from an average
of $93,842 for patients who receive most of their care at UCLA
Medical Center
to $53,432 at the Mayo Clinic’s main teaching hospital in Rochester, Minn.
Also, medical spending averaged $85,729 for those who used Johns Hopkins
Hospital in Baltimore, $78,666 at Massachusetts General
and $55,333 at the Cleveland Clinic.
Differences in the last six months of life were even higher
with spending an average of $52,911 for UCLA patients and $28,763 for those who
used the Mayo hospital, St. Mary's.
According to Dr. John E. Wennberg of Dartmouth Medical
School, the chief author
of the study, doctors and hospitals that provided more care, or more intensive
care, did not necessarily achieve better results for patients.
“Some chronically ill and dying Americans are receiving too
much care – more than they and their families actually want or benefit from.
Contrary to popular assumptions, it’s the volume of services, not the price per
service that accounts for most of the variation in Medicare spending,” Dr.
Wennberg said, according to the New York Times.
“We know that hospitals are dangerous places if you don’t
need to be there,” Dr. Eliot Fisher, who also led the study, said.
The study also found that the patients at UCLA Medical
Center spent 11.6 days in
the intensive care unit on average versus 4.2 days at the Mayo Clinic’s
hospital. A patient at UCLA was visited by a doctor nearly 53 times, versus 24
physicians visits at the Mayo Clinic.
All these findings led the study’s authors to believe that
Medicare could save large amounts of money if patients were treated the same in
all hospitals.
Medicare spending for the population in the study totaled
about $289 billion. If the spending per patient for the entire population
mirrored the rates in Rochester,
Medicare could have saved $50 billion.