“Doubt can be as powerful and sustaining a bond as certainty,”
a character utters with confidence in “Doubt.”
The status between belief and disbelief is portrayed
flawlessly by Meryl Streep, who impersonates a distrustful nun in John Patrick
Shanley’s big screen adaptation of his Tony Award- and Pulitzer Prize-winning play.
Set in the crucial year of 1964 at St. Nicholas, a Catholic
church and school in the Bronx, “Doubt”
depicts a thoroughly constructed clash between Father Flynn (Philip Seymour
Hoffman) and the school’s frightening principal, Sister Aloysius Beauvier
(Meryl Streep), which takes place both inside and outside the minds of the
characters.
The disagreement surrounds the fate of a 12-year-old black boy,
Donald Miller (Joseph Foster II) who studies at St. Nicholas school. He is the
first and only black student in the institute and Sister Aloysius suspects that
Father Flynn sexually abused him.
“Doubt” represents an outstandingly refined piece of work that
aims to deliver utmost results through each of its pieces and thus reveal the
beauty of introspection and interior conflicts.
In spite of the fact that the film’s focal point is the
mystery behind the supposed abuse, the plot manages to analyze other moral
aspects as well. Thus, one should not be surprised to discover analogies that
bring to light philosophical questions, conservative and less traditional
values, the startling difference between inflexibility and candidness, mere
doubt and certainty based on clear evidence. The picture also includes hints on
whether it is apposite to take measures notwithstanding the fact that one does
not have sufficient proof and other suggestions with regard to the limits of
intuition and personal beliefs that are not universally accepted.
Philip Seymour Hoffman’s character inspires goodness and
integrity, doubled by a remarkably charismatic side, which is the sole source
of suspicion, at least for viewers. He often joins his students on different
activities and is not afraid of God when he smokes and has a drink.
Meryl Streep’s persona, on the other hand, is evidently the
villain due to her unflustered assurance and fearsome dictatorship. She wants
to take the helm of every single element in the school and strives to control
other teachers, as well as the students, who are frightened by her cool (and
may I say evil) attitude.
Sister James (Amy Adams) has her doubts with regard to
Father Flynn’s guilt, but Sister Aloysius has none. She is determined to make
justice in her own way, even if all she has got are mere hunches.
While the plot reaches the highest level of intensity throughout
the development of the powerful conflict, it does not fail to examine the
characters from a psychological point of view, without letting anything go
away. It creates the perfect cinematic world for the John Patrick Shanley’s
critically acclaimed play.