The number of heart attacks among nonsmokers in Monroe County
declined by more than two-thirds in the months after a countywide smoking ban
took effect, showed a study led by Indiana
University professors.
According to the researchers, smoking bans can quickly lead
to a considerably improvement in nonsmokers’ health. They based their theory on
the fact that the findings in Monroe County did not match the data in Delaware County,
which has similar demographics but no restriction to smoking.
"This provides really solid evidence of the benefit of the public
smoking ban, and hopefully this will provide a basis for adopting a public
smoking ban in many municipalities and states," said Dong-Chul Seo, an
assistant professor in IU's Department of Applied Health Science and the
study's lead author.
The authorities in Monroe County
forbid workplace smoking or smoking in any indoor public place, except for some
bars.
The study involved only nonsmokers with no previous risk
factors for cardiac disease.
The authors of the study said there was a 70 percent drop in
the number of hospital admissions for heart attacks among non-smoking patients in
Monroe County,
compared to only an 11 percent drop in Delaware County.
Some researchers say that smoking bans might quickly improve
the health of nonsmokers, while others say that it is tough to draw conclusion
based only on one variable.
"There could be other factors that are kind of hidden
that are really driving the difference that's being seen across these counties.
You can certainly from these data say that there's a difference between these
two counties. But you have a harder time concluding that the only reason these
two counties differ is because of the smoking ban," said Bruce Craig,
director of Purdue
University's statistical
consulting group.
However, the researchers’ conclusions match the conclusions of other studies,
which discovered that the number of heart attacks decreased due to cigarette
bans or smoking cessation.
Dr. Stephen J. Jay, a professor of medicine and public health at the Indiana
University School of Medicine explained that substances in smoke, entering the
bloodstream, could contribute to blockages and further more to heart attacks or
strokes.
"What people don't understand is that if you look at active smoking as
well as passive smoking in population studies, you can see that exposure to
smoke, active or passive, is perfectly capable of killing you now," Jay
said.
The American Institutes for Research and Indiana Tobacco Prevention and
Cessation funded the study published in the current issue of the Journal of
drug Education.