 |
|
|
President George W Bush has exempted the Navy from an
environmental law regulating the use of sonar off the California coast, the White House announced
Wednesday.
Bush determined that the Navy needs to use the mid-frequency
sonar to effectively train for anti-submarine warfare "in support of
worldwide operational and combat activities, which are essential to national
security."
"Compliance ... would undermine the Navy's ability to
conduct realistic training exercises that are necessary to ensure the combat
effectiveness of carrier and expeditionary strike groups," the White House
statement said.
Earlier this month, a Los Angeles
federal judge urged the Navy to limit the use of mid-frequency sonar within 12
miles of Southern California, which would
greatly reduce the negative impact on marine life (whales and dolphins)
The decision was made by U.S. District Judge Florence-Marie
Cooper, and it is meant to avoid the use of mid-frequency sonar within the
migrating corridor the various marine mammals use in their journey. According
to federal rules, humans are to wear ear protection when using the sonar.
The Navy and environmental activists have been in a legal
dispute over the practice for years. The Navy had previously proposed a set of
regulations on the use of mid-frequency sonar, but the federal judge completely
disagreed with them. The proposition of the Navy stated that the sonar’s
intensity should be reduced when the marine mammals approached within 1,100
yards, and shut down when the creatures get as close as 200 yards.
As a response to the Navy proposition, the newly stated rule
says that “the court is persuaded that the (protection) scheme proposed by the
navy is grossly inadequate to protect marine mammals from debilitating levels
of sonar exposure.” The judge ordered the sonar to be shut down when the
mammals are within 2,200 yards and the waters to be scouted one hour before the
exercise, in order to identify the possible presence of marine mammals.
The Navy declared itself aware of the damage the sonar
exercises causes, estimating that a series of 14 exercises would temporarily
deafen whales 8,000 times and cause permanent injuries to over 400 mammals, but
said that its soldiers need to be trained somehow.
"By exempting the Navy from basic safeguards under both
federal and state law, the president is flouting the will of Congress, the
decision of the California Coastal Commission, and a ruling by the federal court,"
said Joel Reynolds, the director of mammal protection at the National Resources
Defence Council
© 2007 - 2009 - eFluxMedia