With the presidential
campaigns nearing the end and the elections on November 4,
2008 approaching,
both candidates for president of the United States have come to play their last
card: the reformation of the U.S. health care system.
While
Democrat Barack Obama aims at convincing more people to sign up for employer-based
health care, his counter-candidate John McCain has his mind and his plan set on
doing the exact opposite, by trying to make people switch from employer-based
health care to individual health-care plans. His project seeks to replace the
government’s subvention for employers with tax credit that would enable them to
pay for health-care coverage.
The latter presidential nominee’s revision of the United
States health care system entails taxing health benefits the same way salaries
are now taxed, the fee not being requested in case the person chooses an
individual plan.
Obama, on the other hand, targets medium and large companies
where paying taxes is concerned, asking them to pour money into a fund for the
uninsured if they do not wish to provide their employees with health-care
coverage.
Since the
two plans clash, it comes as no surprise that the two candidates lash. At each
other, of course.
Consequently,
Obama deems McCain’s health-care plan as being a total failure on all accounts,
stating that the credit would not actually go to the person who purchases
coverage, but to the latter’s insurance company.
Moreover, Joseph
Biden, a senior United States Senator from Delaware who has been nominated by the
Democratic Party to run for vice-president of the U.S., reckons that the replacement the
Republican proposes would result in a major tax increase. Nevertheless, analysis
has revealed that the only increase McCain’s plan would give rise to was one in
the number of insured Americans.
In
addition, many seem to think the GOP nominee’s plan, although radical, is
exactly what the system needed, since employer-based health care has managed
to drive it to a standstill.
The current health-care system’s main flaws: discriminating
against self-employed people, not offering employees the possibility to search
for the best prices and benefits and putting people off changing their jobs.
As for Obama’s plan, critics say that it would come to give
the government an unfair and at the same time undesired advantage over private
insurers, because the former is capable of instating price controls and thus cutting
costs. As a result, the number of companies choosing to offer coverage would
rise over the years, leaving the issues mentioned above unresolved.
John McCain’s plan entails offering a $2,500 tax credit for
individuals and $5,000 one for families in order to help them get coverage. Still,
the $5,000 is estimated to be a rather small amount where families below the
middle-class income threshold are concerned.
HSI Network has conducted research that has revealed McCain’s
plan would provide coverage to 27.5 million uninsured Americans, which is two
million more than the number of people Obama’s health-care plan would
accomplish to offer coverage to.