Mr. Bjoern Erik Thon, Norway’s top consumer advocate,
announced his intentions to take Apple Inc. to the government’s Market Council,
in an effort to get the company to allow other digital players, other than the
iPod, to use the iTunes music store.
"Consumers themselves should be able to choose what
music device they would like to use to listen to music bought from the iTunes
Store," said Mr. Thon. His battle with Apple started back in 2006 when he
stated that dictating the technology that customers must use is wrong and filed
an official complaint.
It is a well known fact that once a song is purchased and
downloaded using iTunes, it can be listened to using an iPod but it cannot be
transferred to other player models, such as Microsoft Corp.’s Windows Media
system. Some say that this measure is evened out by the impossibility of
playing on iPods copy-protected tunes sold through non-Apple stores.
So far Apple did not address the issue and has just over a
month, until November 03, to make a decision before Thon proceeds with his
plans. The matter that he is trying to bring light on refers to the fact that
people, at least Norwegians, should have the freedom to choose whatever player
they see fit for their music and should not stick with iTunes just because
Apple wants that. The company uses its digital rights management (DRM) policy
to explain its move, as the DRM is used to prevent illegal copying and
distribution of files.
The announcement was received with enthusiasm by many, and
several countries, including Finland, Denmark, France, Germany and the
Netherlands completely back Norway’s request.
Mr. Thon admitted that over the past two years a certain
progress was indeed recorded, as Apple agreed to several adjustments in its
contracts on how to convert music, but it is still extremely far from what
should be going on. He explained that Apple’s efforts are less than acceptable
and the November 03 deadline should not be taken lightly.
"It's a consumer's right to transfer and play digital
content bought and downloaded from the Internet to the music device he himself
chooses to use," said Thon. "iTunes makes this impossible or at least
difficult, and hence, they act in breach of Norwegian law."
Steve Jobs, Apple’s CEO and co-founder, released a letter last
year on the company’s official Web site, to address the highly debated issue. He
said that these problems were mainly reported in European countries and instead
of complaining about it, people should focus on persuading the music companies such
as Universal, EMI, Sony BMG or Vivendi to make their music available DRM-free.
"Convincing them to license their music to Apple and others DRM-free will
create a truly interoperable music marketplace," said Jobs. "Apple
will embrace this wholeheartedly."
It’s hard to believe that there has been any significant
change in Steve Jobs’ opinion on the matter over the past year and for Apple,
being taken to court and turning this matter on all sides for the next few
years will probably be considered acceptable.