The latest research on the mighty predator Tyrannosaurus rex confirms
the long-hypothesized theory that there is a relationship between it and modern
birds, including chickens and ostriches, scientists say.
Previous fossil studies have already suggested modern birds
were descended from T. rex based on their skeletons.
Now, analyzing bits of protein (samples of collagen)
obtained from tissue in a T. rex fossil, scientists found that birds, not
lizards or other reptiles, are the closest relatives of dinosaurs, according to
a report in Friday’s edition of the journal Science.
“These results match predications made from skeletal
anatomy, providing the first molecular evidence for the evolutionary
relationships of a non-avian dinosaur,” Chris Organ, a postdoctoral researcher
in biology at
“Our results at the genetic level basically agree with what
has been seen in skeletal data. There is more than a 90 percent probability
that the grouping of T rex with living birds is real,” John M. Asara of
Harvard, who led the analysis, said.
The proteins for the analysis were processed from tissue
recovered deep in the bones of a 68 million-year-old T. rex excavated in 2003 by
John R. Horner of
Dr. Asara and Dr. Organ reached their conclusions after they
compared the dinosaur protein with similar protein from several dozen species
of modern birds, reptiles and other animals.
The researchers also studied material recovered from a
mastodon fossil and concluded it was related to modern elephants.
Some scientists saying that protein preservation over tens
of millions of years should not be possible contested the findings. They went
even further questioning the origin of Dr. Asara’s sequences and saying they
might not come from an ancient R. rex. In their theory, proteins from some
other biological source could have somehow contaminated the dinosaur remains.
There is also another issue on which they built their
skepticism, more specifically, the small size of the sequences included in this
research.
“They have a very tiny bit of data relative to the size of
the collagen molecule. What’s going to be really convincing is to actually see
some more sequences. If [preservation of dinosaur proteins] is a ubiquitous
occurrence, then that should be forthcoming,” Peggy Ostrom, a biologist at
No matter how contested this study is, it still adds to the growing evidence that birds are descended directly from a group of dinosaurs that grew feathers, possibly as a form of thermal insulation, before they learnt to fly.
In
The National Institutes of Health, National Science Foundation, Paul F. Glenn Foundation and the David and Lucille Packard Foundation funded the research appearing in the journal Science.